cashdFootball Cards
Resale value
There's no single "typical" football card price — a common card is worth cents and a graded Brady rookie is worth thousands. Scan your card in Cashd to price the exact player, set, and condition against current eBay listings.
Priced item by item. Scan yours for a price on your exact item.
Most-Searched Football Cards by Player
The players whose cards drive the market, and the rookie cards collectors look for. Base versions are far more affordable than graded, numbered, or autographed copies.
- Tom Brady2000 rookies — Playoff Contenders Championship Ticket autograph (the grail), Bowman Chrome, and SP Authentic.
- Patrick Mahomes2017 Panini Prizm is the flagship rookie; National Treasures rookie patch autographs sit far above it.
- Joe Burrow, Justin Herbert & Jalen Hurts2020 Panini Prizm rookies — the main modern QB class.
- Josh Allen & Lamar Jackson2018 Panini Prizm rookies — prices track their MVP-level seasons.
- C.J. Stroud, Caleb Williams & Jayden Daniels2023–2024 rookies — newest QB market, most volatile prices.
- Travis Kelce2013 Panini Prizm rookie — demand well beyond typical tight-end cards.
- Joe Montana1981 Topps rookie — the classic vintage QB card, strongest in high grades.
- Jerry Rice1986 Topps rookie — the most sought-after '80s football card.
- Peyton Manning1998 rookies (Bowman Chrome, Playoff Contenders autograph).
- Walter Payton & Jim Brown1976 Topps (Payton) and 1958 Topps (Brown) rookies — vintage cards where condition is everything.
- Junk wax era (1987–1994)Most cards from these years were overproduced. Pull out the Hall of Fame rookies; the rest usually sell in bulk lots.
What moves the price
- 01
Quarterbacks drive the market — QB rookie cards consistently outsell other positions.
- 02
Rookie cards from major sets (Panini Prizm, Topps Chrome, Bowman Chrome) are what collectors chase.
- 03
Grade multiplies value: PSA 10 copies of star rookies sell for many times a PSA 9.
- 04
Numbered parallels, autographs, and rookie patch autos (like National Treasures RPAs) sit in a much higher tier.
- 05
Big games move prices fast — football's short season makes playoff results visible in the market almost immediately.
- 06
Most cards from 1987–1994 were overproduced and rarely worth more than a few dollars.
The full story
Football card value is driven by the player, the specific card, and its condition. Quarterback rookie cards dominate the market — Tom Brady, Patrick Mahomes, and the current young QBs — with vintage Hall of Famers like Joe Montana and Jerry Rice holding steady demand among collectors.
Prices move with the season: a Super Bowl run or MVP year can lift a player's rookie cards within days. Meanwhile, most cards from the late '80s and '90s were mass-produced and are worth very little. Scan yours in Cashd to price your exact card against current eBay sales.
Questions
Are my old football cards worth anything?
Most late-'80s and '90s cards aren't — they were printed in huge numbers. Key rookies of Hall of Famers (Jerry Rice's 1986 Topps, Joe Montana's 1981 Topps) and anything older and well-preserved are the exceptions. Scan a few in Cashd to spot the ones worth listing.
What is the most valuable Tom Brady card?
His 2000 Playoff Contenders Championship Ticket rookie autograph is the grail, with record sales in the millions for top grades. More attainable Brady rookies include 2000 Bowman Chrome and SP Authentic.
Should I grade my football cards?
Only the ones worth it — star rookies in clean condition. Check what the raw card sells for first; grading fees don't make sense on common cards.
How does Cashd price my football card?
Cashd identifies the player and card from your photo and prices it against current comparable eBay listings, rather than a generic category guess.
Got a Football Cards?
Snap it and get a price for your exact one.
Cashd may earn a commission from eBay links on this page. Prices are market data, not an appraisal.