cashdSquishmallows
Used resale value · updated Oct 16
$9 – $16
Typical $13▲ 5.1% · 11d
Snap a photo · free · about 30 seconds
Middle 50% of 86 used listings on eBay US. Asking prices; sales usually land 10–20% lower.
What Collectors Look For
The details that move a Squishmallow above the typical range.
- Named rare charactersA small set of characters collectors hunt by name; check sold listings for yours.
- Discontinued and early releasesNo longer made, so supply only shrinks.
- Store exclusives and limited dropsSold through one retailer or a limited run.
- Large sizesBigger sizes sell for more, but cost more to ship.
What moves the price
- 01
The character's name is the price — collectors search by name, and a few characters are worth many times the rest.
- 02
Early and discontinued characters hold value better than ones currently on shelves.
- 03
Store exclusives and limited releases sell separately from regular stock.
- 04
Tags matter: the hang tag (with the character's name and bio) adds value; missing tags lower it.
- 05
Size: larger Squishmallows sell for more, and shipping cost matters to buyers on big ones.
Listed now on eBay
- Squishmallow Pink Milkshake Love/Hearts 9" Soft Stuffed Toy 2023 (No Hang Tags)$13
- Squishmallows Edwin Banana Cream Pie Plush 16” Preowned Yellow Discoloration$13
- Squishmallows "Fifi" The Red Fox - 10 " Plush Mini Backpack$13
- Squishmallows Zumir the Peppermint Moose Green & Red Plush Holiday $13
- Pokémon Bellibolt 20" Squishmallow Plush$13
The full story
Squishmallows are made in enormous numbers, so most of them resell for around $10–15 — less than they cost new. A few are different: early and discontinued characters, limited and store-exclusive releases, and the handful of characters collectors chase by name.
Tag condition, size, and the character's exact name decide the price. The live range below is what a typical Squishmallow listing sells for right now.
Most Squishmallows sell for about $10–15 used. Rare characters and exclusives are the exceptions — scan yours in Cashd for a price on the exact character.
Used (eBay listings): the Squishmallows averaged $12 on Oct 4 and $13 on Oct 16, so prices rose 5.1% over 13 days of tracking. The lowest daily median was $10 (Oct 6) and the highest $14 (Oct 9).
Questions
Are Squishmallows worth any money?
Most sell for $10–15 used. Rare, early or exclusive characters can sell for much more. Check the live range above, then scan yours for the exact character.
How do I know if my Squishmallow is rare?
Search its exact name and size on eBay sold listings. If it consistently sells above the typical range, it's one collectors are after. The hang tag tells you the name.
Should I sell Squishmallows one at a time or as a lot?
Sell rare characters on their own. Bundle common ones into lots — buyers pay less per piece, but they sell much faster.
Got a Squishmallows?
Snap it and get a price for your exact one.
Cashd may earn a commission from eBay links on this page. Prices are market data, not an appraisal.